2011 (23 entries)
1st Theodore Harwood, Eta Delta at Hillsdale College
2nd Ilan Gonzalez-Hirshfeld, Eta Mu at the University of California, Davis
3rd Samuel D. Amos, Theta Omega at John Carroll University
Honorable Mention: Ryan Vinson, Beta Delta at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville
2010 (21 entries)
1st Regina M. Loehr, Eta Zeta at Truman State University
2nd Ilan Gonzalez-Hirshfeld, Eta Mu at the University of California, Davis
3rd Jared Howard, Epsilon Iota at the University of Florida
Honorable Mentions: Heather Outland, Gamma Omega at Baylor University; Jennifer N. Easler, Delta Chi at St. Olaf College
2009 (37 entries)
1st Evan Ward, Zeta Chi at Xavier University
2nd Van Le, Eta Zeta at Truman State University
3rd Maggie Hoyt, Epsilon Kappa at Brigham Young University
Honorable Mentions: Patrick V. Neff, Theta Omega at John Carroll University; Scott Sorenson, Eta Mu at the University of California, Davis
2008 (23 entries)
1st Thomas Halvorsen, Delta Chi at St. Olaf College
2nd Lisa York, Delta Chi at St. Olaf College
3rd Kyle Helms, Epsilon Iota at the University of Florida
Honorable Mentions: Ellen Cole, Gamma Sigma at the University of Texas at Austin; Heather Outland, Gamma Omega at Baylor University
2007 (28 entries)
1st Frederick Bowman, Zeta Chi at Xavier University
2nd Thomas Halvorsen, Delta Chi at St. Olaf College
3rd Kevin Kimball, Eta Delta at Hillsdale College
2006 (28 entries)
1st Joshua Rasmussen, Gamma Sigma at the University of Texas at Austin
2nd Dan Walin, Gamma Omega at Baylor University
3rd Kevin Kimball, Eta Delta at Hillsdale College
2005 (18 entries)
1st Jason Nethercut, Gamma Sigma at the University of Texas at Austin
2nd Ane Kirstine Wynn, Delta Chi at St. Olaf College
3rd Tom Hendrickson, Zeta Sigma at the University of Minnesota
2004
1st Jason Nethercut, Gamma Sigma at the University of Texas at Austin
2nd Christopher Schifani, Delta Chi at St. Olaf College
3rd Kenji Yamada, Eta Mu at the University of California, Davis
Honorable Mention: Andrew Mihailoff, Omicron at University of Pennsylvania